The time that a firm can stay a monopoly needs to be taken into account. And barriers of entry.
If they go too crazy with their prices, I can simply wait a year or two for others to reverse engineer it and buy it cheaper from competition. This is why pharma can charge such high prices, but Intel was much more limited in their pricing power.
And if profits are too high ROIC for entering the industry and competing becomes attractive enough. Anytime in any industry if ROIC becomes attractive enough it will attract more competitors and investment. So if you charge a lower price you might get more customers now, reverse engineering might take longer and not to speak of issues with regulators.
Then there are middlemen like distributors making it harder to price vs different customers. Controlling these distribution networks might be non-trivial and might be fairly easy for customers to hide their identity when buying from you even with direct sales.
That is usually the sticking point with game theory questions like this, there are always some hidden factors you forget to take into account, unless you have deep real world experience in an industry.
also, further explanation of the nordhaustt 2% value capture would be fascinating...have read that stat multiple times, but never seen great explanation. Although is has massive implications, any place that you or others explore that would be fascinating!
The consumers can be better off or worse off. That’s true. But consider the case where there is a fixed cost and the good won’t be produced without price discrimination. Then clearly the consumers are better off under price discrimination since their surplus goes from zero to the two green rectangles.
this is a critical distinction. If price discrimination is needed to make the item /serve profitable at all, then you are correct consumer benefits. but in MANY cases where the product will be made anyway, price discrimination and manipulative market power / concentration shafts the consumer. maybe not a 101 model, but any models that accurately bifurcate this situation?
Great Post!
Thanks :)
The time that a firm can stay a monopoly needs to be taken into account. And barriers of entry.
If they go too crazy with their prices, I can simply wait a year or two for others to reverse engineer it and buy it cheaper from competition. This is why pharma can charge such high prices, but Intel was much more limited in their pricing power.
And if profits are too high ROIC for entering the industry and competing becomes attractive enough. Anytime in any industry if ROIC becomes attractive enough it will attract more competitors and investment. So if you charge a lower price you might get more customers now, reverse engineering might take longer and not to speak of issues with regulators.
Then there are middlemen like distributors making it harder to price vs different customers. Controlling these distribution networks might be non-trivial and might be fairly easy for customers to hide their identity when buying from you even with direct sales.
That is usually the sticking point with game theory questions like this, there are always some hidden factors you forget to take into account, unless you have deep real world experience in an industry.
also, further explanation of the nordhaustt 2% value capture would be fascinating...have read that stat multiple times, but never seen great explanation. Although is has massive implications, any place that you or others explore that would be fascinating!
Hm... why are consumers better off? It seems like they would be worse off. It's simply that their surplus gets turned into profit...
The consumers can be better off or worse off. That’s true. But consider the case where there is a fixed cost and the good won’t be produced without price discrimination. Then clearly the consumers are better off under price discrimination since their surplus goes from zero to the two green rectangles.
this is a critical distinction. If price discrimination is needed to make the item /serve profitable at all, then you are correct consumer benefits. but in MANY cases where the product will be made anyway, price discrimination and manipulative market power / concentration shafts the consumer. maybe not a 101 model, but any models that accurately bifurcate this situation?
Okay, I'm late here, but surely it's only the consumers with high WTP that are shafted -- the rest are better off?